Italian Sandwiches for Sale in Chicago, IL

You may have heard of the meatball sub or the Italian beef sandwich or seen it on a few menus at local restaurants around Chicago. But did you know these sandwiches are deeply rooted in Chicago’s culinary history? There’s a reason why these two Italian sandwiches are popular and have become a staple in the city’s foodie scene. From their scrumptious flavors to their Italian authenticity, these sandwiches are indeed something to behold. Come to Pequod’s Pizza to try these iconic Italian sandwiches and dive into what makes them so good.

Meatball Sandwich

Pequod’s Pizza meatball sandwich is a flavorful meal that hits the spot for diners wanting Italian fare for lunch or dinner. We start with a fresh bread roll that is soft yet strong enough to hold the hearty meatballs in place. Our meatballs feature a quality blend of ground beef with breadcrumbs and eggs, topped with a savory marinara sauce that contains cheese for the perfect complement to this standout dish. Take a bite out of this classic Italian sub and enjoy the combination of plump meatballs, tender bread, and a delicious sauce that keeps the ingredients moist.

Italian Beef

The Italian beef sandwich is a Chicago classic we’re proud to have on our menu. We commit to providing authentic Italian flavors and put lots of care into preparing this beloved dish at Pequod’s Pizza. Our base Italian beef sandwich comes with tender, thinly sliced beef and a flavorful au jus on the side for dipping into and adding savory juice to every bite. 

Want to amp it up and impress your tastebuds? We offer various toppings and condiment add-ons to enhance the sandwich’s taste. Add sweet peppers and melted cheese for a tangy, gooey blend of impactful flavors. Or add hot peppers if you’re looking for a kick of spice with each bite.

History of the Two Sandwiches in Chicago

Like our late founder, Burt Katz, a born-and-raised Chicagoan, we pride ourselves on keeping up with traditions. This sentiment is especially true regarding our Pequod’s Pizza Italian sandwiches because they allow us to showcase our love for Chicago and its rich culinary heritage.

Take the Italian beef sandwich, for example. Despite its unknown origins, this classic Italian sub first appeared in Chicago in the early 1900s. Italian immigrants who lived here would slowly roast tough cuts of meat in a spicy broth. Once the meat was tender, they cut it into thin slices and layered them onto a fresh loaf of Italian bread. 

The Italian beef sandwich became a staple at weddings and family gatherings, gaining so much popularity over the years that in the 1930s, it began to claim its stake in the restaurant industry. This classic Italian sandwich combines tradition and unbeatable flavor, which is why we love to offer it on our Pequod’s Pizza menu.

The meatball sub carries a similar background story, with many thanks to the millions of Italian immigrants who came to America. Food accessibility looked different here in Chicago compared to their home country; meat was abundantly available. Because of this abundance, Italian families began integrating more beef into their diets, making the meatball a crowning staple in their cuisine. 

The meatball sandwich was invented around the turn of the 20th century, piling hefty meatballs covered in red sauce onto soft Italian rolls for a filling meal that’s a delightful complement to a day of hard work or family outing. It’s a hearty Italian sandwich we proudly serve on our menu.

Pequod’s Pizza: A Sandwich Haven

Peqoud’s Pizza is more than just an award-winning deep-dish pizza joint; it’s a sandwich haven slinging iconic Italian sandwiches for lunch and dinner. Just like we do with our pizzas, we only use the highest quality ingredients for our sandwiches while adhering to traditional recipes so you get the best taste of Chicago every time you visit. Plus, we offer an exceptional dining experience in a cozy setting with brick-lined walls and comfy booths, or you can grab a stool by the bar and catch the latest game by your favorite Chicago team.

Satisfy Your Sandwich Cravings

When you order an Italian sandwich at Pequod’s Pizza, you into a world of customization where you’re free to choose your favorite toppings and sides to complement your meal. Determine the juiciness level of your sandwich by ordering it dry, dipped, or with a side of au jus. Add on melted cheese for an insatiable cheese pull, sweet or hot peppers for extra tang or spice, or our classic marinara sauce for more flavor. Choose a side to go with your sandwich, like garlic bread or French fries, or order hot or sweet peppers or marinara on the side to satisfy your cravings.

Ready to indulge in a mouthwatering Italian sandwich at Pequod’s Pizza? Choose a Pequod’s Pizza location for “sandwiches near me” and reserve a table so you don’t miss out on a unique dining experience. If you prefer to enjoy your meal in the comfort of your own home, order online for food delivery in the Chicago area. 

For dining or delivery from our Chicago location:

• Location: 2207 N. Clybourn Ave., Chicago.
• Hours: 11 a.m. to 2 a.m. Monday through Saturday and 11 a.m. to midnight on Sunday.
• Contact: 773-327-1512.

For dining or delivery from our Morton Grove location:

• Location: 8520 Fernald Ave., Morton Grove.
• Hours: 11 a.m. to 9:30 p.m. Monday through Thursday, 11 a.m. to 11:30 p.m. on Friday, noon to 11:30 p.m. on Saturday, and noon to 9:30 p.m. on Sunday. 
• Contact: 847-470-9161.

Embark on a Sandwich Adventure at Pequod’s Pizza

When you dine at Pequod’s Pizza, you get more than just a meal. Celebrate Chicago’s rich culinary heritage with a stop at our restaurant for delectable Italian sandwiches, fresh salads, deep-dish pizza, and more. Make a reservation to dine in, grab your meal to-go, or schedule a Pequod’s Pizza delivery from a Chicago location near you. Did you love your sandwich? Share your experience on social media or leave an online review to encourage others to give us a try.